7 Ice Cream Shops We Love In Tallahassee & Beyond
About Tallahassee August 27, 2026
About Tallahassee August 27, 2026
Tallahassee and nearby areas are serving up seven of the sweetest spots for a cool treat and as we all know, the weather is pretty spicy a majority of the year around here so we thought we'd share this useful list for the moments you'd like to indulge and cool down! Make sure to come back and tell us which shops you tried out and what you think!
Enjoy your breakfast or lunch, then step back in time and up to their vintage soda fountain for a sweet treat. They serve artisanal and intricate ice cream creations, malts, shakes, and so many more sweets to satisfy your cravings! While there, you can watch them make their handmade, ornate candies. Families can enjoy playing board games and shopping in their nostalgic toy store. Lofty Pursuits is a must-visit when you're in Tallahassee!
Where real ice cream is made fresh in-house! They've created over 150 recipes exclusive to Bruster's, which rotate daily, so it's always a surprise as to which 24 or more flavors will be available when you're ready to satisfy your sweet tooth. For a sweet, light crunch to go with your favorite ice cream flavor, their waffle cones and bowls are baked fresh daily, too! Bruster's offers a variety of sweet treats, from shakes and sundaes to banana splits and more. Head to Bruster's for a delicious taste of freshly made ice cream!
A small business with BIG flavor! The snowball isn't a snow cone with crunch; it's lighter, smoother, and more delicate. It's a New Orleans original! Big Easy Snowballs brings New Orleans-style shaved ice to Tallahassee. They offer 150 different syrup flavors, from the basics to unique flavors like Cajun Red Hot, Creole Cream Cheese, and Wedding Cake. Their signature house special is a Stuffed Snowball, where they stuff French vanilla soft-serve ice cream right into the middle of the snowball! How creative and delicious is that?!
Offers refreshing Italian Ice with more than 40 fun flavors that rotate throughout the year, along with delicious soft-serve ice cream and Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches. But where else can you get refreshing Italian Ice layered with your favorite soft-serve ice cream and various toppings, if you like? This is what Jeremiah's Italian Ice is famous for—the Jelati! It's the perfect combination of Italian Ice and soft-serve ice cream! Why not?! 3 Locations to serve you.
Offers more than just ice cream—they offer homemade brittle-infused ice cream! There are so many flavors of brittle to choose from, including peanut, spicy peanut, ,hazelnut, pecan, macadamia, and many more. Barb also offers seed brittles, such as sunflower and pumpkin. She even offers "virgin" brittle for those looking for a nut-free option. Now, pair that delicious brittle with homemade ice cream, and Barb has created a special sweet treat many of us would love to try!
In Thomasville, Georgia, offers its Original Recipe Ice Cream in dozens of distinctive flavors. Kilwins is known for its premium-quality ice cream with a rich texture and extra-creamy taste, made with quality ingredients. Have a special occasion coming up? Celebrate with a Kilwins Gourmet Ice Cream Cake! Now that's fancy! Just a short drive from Tallahassee, Thomasville is a great little getaway when you're craving something sweet.
In Morven, Georgia, is for all of you peach lovers out there! Why not take a picturesque drive to Lawson Peach Shed? This quaint roadside stop has a rustic atmosphere and has been packing and shipping its own peaches from its family farm since 1961. During peach season, they offer fresh peaches, peach ice cream and peach lemonade and other peach inspired treats.! Take your time, head onto the porch, and rock in one of their rocking chairs while enjoying your peachy sweet treat! You may want to call or email before you head out to verify days and hours open.
About Tallahassee
About Tallahassee
For Realtors
The Real Estate Market
Home Design and Decor
Tallahassee Local Events
Tallahassee Local Events
Experience the difference that exceptional service and results can make in your real estate journey. Vellinda Hittinger is dedicated to providing personalized attention and expert guidance to each client, ensuring that your unique needs are met with the highest standards of professionalism.
